The Lincoln County War was a violent feud in Lincoln County, New Mexico Territory, fought mainly in 1878. Two groups of merchants were struggling for control of the county's trade and its government beef contracts. On one side were Lawrence G. Murphy and James J. Dolan, whose store dominated the county. On the other were the young Englishman John H. Tunstall and the lawyer Alexander McSween, backed by the cattleman John Chisum. Each side had lawmen and hired gunmen on its side, and the quarrel moved from the courts to the street. The war made the name of Billy the Kid, and his legend has kept it famous.
Background
Lincoln began in the 1850s as a Hispanic farming village on the Rio Bonito called La Placita del Rio Bonito. In 1869 the county and town were renamed after Abraham Lincoln (see Lincoln, New Mexico).
In 1873 L. G. Murphy opened a large store in Lincoln. Locals called it "The House", because it controlled almost all trade in the county. Murphy's firm also held the contracts to supply beef to the Mescalero Apache reservation and to Fort Stanton. By the mid-1870s the business was largely in the hands of his partner James Dolan. Tunstall arrived in late 1876 and, with McSween and Chisum, set up a rival store, a bank and a cattle business aimed at the same contracts. A quarrel over a dead partner's insurance money, which McSween had collected and refused to hand over to The House, gave Dolan's side a legal weapon. Small ranchers who had clashed with Chisum, and gunmen such as the Jesse Evans Gang, sided with Murphy and Dolan. Both sides included Anglo and Hispanic men; Hispanic riders such as José Chávez y Chávez fought alongside McSween's men.
The war
- 18 February 1878. A court order allowed Sheriff William Brady to seize property said to belong to McSween, and it took in Tunstall's horses as well. A posse caught up with Tunstall on the road and shot him dead. His ranch hands, Billy among them, saw it from a distance.
- March 1878. Tunstall's men, deputised by a local justice of the peace, formed the Regulators. They captured two of the posse men, Buck Morton and Frank Baker, who were both killed before they reached Lincoln. The Regulators said the prisoners had tried to escape; accounts differ. Governor Samuel B. Axtell then ruled that the Regulators had no legal authority.
- 1 April 1878. Regulators ambushed Sheriff Brady and his deputy George Hindman on Lincoln's main street and killed both. George W. Peppin later took over as sheriff.
- 4 April 1878. At Blazer's Mill the Regulators fought Andrew "Buckshot" Roberts. Roberts mortally wounded their captain, Dick Brewer, before dying himself.
- Spring 1878. Raids and killings went on across the county.
- July 1878, the Battle of Lincoln. McSween led his men back into Lincoln, and for five days the two sides fired on each other from houses and stores. On the last day troops under Lieutenant Colonel N. A. M. Dudley came from Fort Stanton and camped in the town. Accounts differ on whether their presence helped Peppin's side; a military court of inquiry in 1879 cleared Dudley. On the evening of 19 July McSween's house was set on fire. McSween was shot dead in his back yard, and the Kid escaped from the burning building.
Aftermath
President Rutherford B. Hayes removed Axtell and appointed Lew Wallace, a former Union general and soon to be the author of Ben-Hur, as governor. The Army was allowed to help civil officers, and the fighting died away. Murphy died of cancer in October 1878. In November Wallace offered an amnesty, and most of the gunmen went free. On 18 February 1879, a year to the day after Tunstall's death, McSween's lawyer Huston Chapman was murdered in Lincoln. Billy later met Wallace and offered to testify about the killing in return for a pardon, but he was never pardoned.
Billy the Kid alone was convicted for the killings of the war. Pat Garrett captured him in December 1880. In April 1881 he was tried at Mesilla for Brady's murder and sentenced to hang, but on 28 April he escaped from the Lincoln jail, killing two deputies. Garrett shot him dead at Fort Sumner on 14 July 1881.
Much of Lincoln is now a state historic site. It includes the old county courthouse from which the Kid escaped, the Tunstall store and the torreón, a stone defensive tower.
Dates
Accounts differ on when the war began and ended. The rivalry built up from Tunstall's arrival in late 1876 and through 1877, but the shooting began with Tunstall's murder in February 1878. Some historians end the war with McSween's death in July 1878, some with Chapman's murder in February 1879, and some with the Kid's death in July 1881. This wiki dates the war to 1878, with its roots in 1876–77 and its aftermath running to 1881. Accounts also differ on whether the Battle of Lincoln began on 14 or 15 July.
Legend and history
- Billy as the hero. Films often make the Kid the leader of the Regulators and a loyal avenger of Tunstall. In fact Dick Brewer and then others led the band, and the Kid was one young gunman among many. His fame came mostly after the war.
- "The most dangerous street in America". Hayes is said to have called Lincoln's main street this, but the remark is unproven.
In Westerns
The war has been retold many times, usually around Billy the Kid: The Kid from Texas (1950), The Left Handed Gun (1958), Chisum (1970), with John Wayne as John Chisum, Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1973), Young Guns (1988) and Young Guns II (1990).
Key facts
- Main fighting: February to July 1878 (rivalry from 1876–77; aftermath to 1881; accounts differ)
- Place: Lincoln and Lincoln County, New Mexico Territory
- Murphy–Dolan side: Lawrence G. Murphy, James J. Dolan, Sheriff William Brady, later Sheriff George W. Peppin, the Jesse Evans Gang
- Tunstall–McSween side: John H. Tunstall, Alexander McSween, John Chisum, the Regulators, William H. Bonney ("Billy the Kid")
- Key events: Tunstall killed (18 February 1878); Brady killed (1 April 1878); Battle of Lincoln (July 1878)
- Ended by: the appointment of Governor Lew Wallace, Army support for civil officers and Wallace's amnesty of November 1878
- Main fighting in 1878: it began with Tunstall's killing on 18 February 1878 (Encyclopedia of the Great Plains; Garrett, 1882). Pat Garrett wrote in 1882 that trouble had been 'brewing since the summer of 1876' and began 'in earnest in the spring of 1877', referring to earlier cattle disputes; the NM Historic Sites page dates the war 1878–1881. Accounts differ on its start and end.
- Two merchant factions fought over the county's trade and government beef contracts: Lawrence G. Murphy and James J. Dolan ('The House') against John H. Tunstall and Alexander McSween, backed by cattleman John Chisum (NM Historic Sites; Encyclopedia of the Great Plains).
- Tunstall was shot dead on 18 February 1878 by members of a sheriff's posse (Encyclopedia of the Great Plains; Garrett, 1882; Wikipedia).
- Sheriff William Brady and Deputy George Hindman were killed in an ambush in Lincoln on 1 April 1878 by Regulators, including Billy the Kid (Garrett, 1882; Encyclopedia of the Great Plains; Territory v. Bonney court records, 1878).
- The battle in Lincoln began on 14 July 1878 and ended on 19 July with McSween's house burned and McSween killed (Encyclopedia of the Great Plains; Garrett, 1882, ch. XII, who calls it a three days' fight).
- Governor Lew Wallace offered an amnesty to end the war; Billy the Kid was the only participant convicted for its killings (Encyclopedia of the Great Plains; NM State Records Center and Archives).
- Legend vs history: the line that President Hayes called Lincoln's main street 'the most dangerous street in America' is widely repeated but no primary source for it has been found.
See also
Gallery 1

Sources
- Lincoln County War - Encyclopedia of the Great Plains (University of Nebraska–Lincoln) plainshumanities.unl.edu
- Lincoln Historic Site: History - New Mexico Historic Sites nmhistoricsites.dca.nm.gov
- Billy the Kid primary sources - New Mexico State Records Center and Archives srca.nm.gov
- Pat F. Garrett, The Authentic Life of Billy, the Kid (1882) (contemporary) - Project Gutenberg Australia gutenberg.net.au
- Robert M. Utley, 'Billy the Kid and the Lincoln County War', New Mexico Historical Review 61:2 (1986) digitalrepository.unm.edu
- Lincoln County War - Britannica britannica.com
- Lincoln County War - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1784900 wikidata.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Map of Lincoln NM 1872-1881.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Torreon - Lincoln Co.jpg commons.wikimedia.org

