TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
History › Wounded Knee Massacre

Wounded Knee Massacre (1890)

29 December 1890 · Wounded Knee Creek, Pine Ridge reservation, South Dakota

Wounded Knee was the clash on 29 December 1890 at Wounded Knee Creek, South Dakota, between the US 7th Cavalry and Big Foot's band of Minneconjou Lakota, joined by refugees from Sitting Bull's Hunkpapa camp. It began while soldiers were disarming the band. Roughly 150 to 300 Lakota and about 31 soldiers died.Sources: The Ghost-Dance Religion and the Sioux Outbreak of 1890 (14th Annual Report, Bureau of Ethnology, Part 2), Government Printing Office, 1896 (accessed 27 October 2026) · "The Wounded Knee Interviews of Eli S. Ricker", ed. Donald F. Danker, Nebraska History 62 (1981), History Nebraska, 1906–1907 interviews; 1981 edition (accessed 27 October 2026) · Omaha Daily Bee, 13 February 1891, p. 1 ("Col. Forsythe Sustained": Miles endorsement, Schofield, Proctor decision), Omaha Bee (accessed 27 October 2026)

Summary

On 29 December 1890 soldiers of the 7th Cavalry under Colonel James W. Forsyth were disarming Big Foot's band, which had surrendered the day before and was camped under guard at Wounded Knee Creek, about 20 miles north-east of Pine Ridge Agency [1]. A shot was fired during the search, and within minutes soldiers and warriors were fighting at close quarters. Artillery then fired into the camp. Most of the men died near the council ground, but many women and children were killed as they fled, some of them miles away [1][6].

The Army called it a battle; Lakota survivors and later critics called it a massacre. This page uses both words: the opening struggle between armed men was a fight, and the killing of fleeing women and children after resistance had ended was, in the words of the government ethnologist James Mooney, "simply a massacre" [1].

Background: the Ghost Dance and the alarm of 1890

In 1889 and 1890 a new religious movement, the Ghost Dance, spread to the Lakota reservations from the Paiute prophet Wovoka in Nevada. His own message, as written down for a visiting delegation, was peaceable: "You must not hurt anybody or do harm to anyone. You must not fight. Do right always" [1]. Some Lakota teachers went further. Mooney recorded that Short Bull told his followers "the guns of the soldiers would be rendered harmless and the white race itself would soon be annihilated" [1].

The movement took hold among hungry and resentful people. After the Lakota gave up about half their remaining land in 1889, Congress cut the beef issue at Pine Ridge by a million pounds, although they had been "expressly and repeatedly told" their rations would not suffer. Mooney named the causes of the unrest as the decay of the old life, "repeated neglect of promises made by the government", and "hunger" [1].

On 15 November 1890 Agent Daniel Royer at Pine Ridge "telegraphed that the Indians were wild and crazy and that at least a thousand soldiers were needed" [1]. Troops arrived, and bands of dancers gathered in the Badlands.

On 15 December 1890 Lakota agency police went to arrest Sitting Bull, the Hunkpapa leader, at his home on the Grand River on the Standing Rock reservation. His followers resisted and shot Lieutenant Bull Head of the police, and Sitting Bull was shot dead by Bull Head and Sergeant Red Tomahawk. Six police died [1]. Some of Sitting Bull's frightened followers fled south and joined Big Foot's Minneconjou on the Cheyenne River.

Big Foot's band and the surrender

Big Foot (also called Spotted Elk) led a band of Minneconjou Lakota from the Cheyenne River reservation, which its agent called "very much excited over the coming of the messiah". Big Foot told Colonel Edwin Sumner he had "100 of his own Indians and 38 from Standing Rock (Sitting Bull's band)" [1].

After Sitting Bull's death the band set out for Pine Ridge. The survivors Joseph Horn Cloud and Dewey Beard said Oglala chiefs there, Red Cloud among them, had invited Big Foot to "help make peace" [11]. General Nelson Miles had ordered Big Foot's arrest, so the Army treated the move as defiance.

On 28 December the band met troops under Major Samuel Whitside. Big Foot, sick with pneumonia, "raised a white flag, advanced into the open country, and asked for a parley. This was refused by Major Whitside, who demanded an unconditional surrender, which was at once given" [1]. At Wounded Knee Creek Whitside counted "120 men and 250 women and children" [1]. Forsyth arrived that night, bringing the force to "470 men, as against a total of 106 warriors", with four Hotchkiss guns [1]. A tent was put up for the sick chief, and Forsyth sent "his own surgeon, Dr Glennan, to wait on him" [1][11].

The disarming

Next morning the men were called to a council and told to give up their guns. The first group returned "with only two guns". A search of the tipis found "about forty rifles, most of which, however, were old and of little value" [1]. Soldiers then searched the men themselves, while the medicine man Yellow Bird was "blowing on an eagle-bone whistle, and urging them to resistance", telling the men that their ghost shirts would protect them [1]. Horn Cloud remembered Big Foot, too ill to sit up for long, trying to calm his people, and telling them, "Boys, do not be mad, let them do it" [11].

Who fired first: two accounts

The sources agree that the fighting began with a shot from a Lakota man's gun during the search, but not on whether it was deliberate.

The first account: a deliberate shot. In the account Mooney assembled in 1891, Yellow Bird "threw a handful of dust into the air, when, as if this were the signal, a young Indian, said to have been Black Fox from Cheyenne river, drew a rifle from under his blanket and fired at the soldiers" [1]. The Omaha Bee reported next day that the warriors "jerked guns from under their blankets" [8]. At a council in Washington in February 1891, two Pine Ridge Lakota spoke. Turning Hawk blamed "a crazy man, a young man of very bad influence and in fact a nobody", who "fired his gun". Spotted Horse, who was there as a scout, said "the first shot killed this officer" [3]. The Dakota physician Charles Eastman reached the field afterwards and wrote that "a reckless and desperate young Indian fired the first shot" [6]. Mooney concluded that "the Indians were responsible for the engagement" [1].

The second account: a gun that went off in a struggle. Two brothers from Big Foot's band told it differently to the Nebraska judge and collector Eli S. Ricker. Joseph Horn Cloud spoke to him in 1906 and lost both parents and two brothers that day. Dewey Beard spoke to him in 1907 and lost his wife and baby son. Both described a deaf man (Beard names him Black Coyote) who held his gun over his head and would not give it up without payment. Three sergeants seized him from behind. As they struggled, Horn Cloud said, "the gun went off, elevated in the air at an angle of about 45 degrees" [11]. Beard said "the muzzle pointed upward toward the east and the gun was discharged". In their telling no signal was given, and the soldiers answered at once with a volley [11]. The Army's own interpreter, Philip Wells, also told Ricker that the first gun went off pointing "into the air, over the soldiers' heads", although he said several young warriors then threw off their blankets and drew their guns [11].

This page does not choose between the two accounts; neither can now be proved.

The fighting and the pursuit

The soldiers' first volley was fired at such close range "that their guns were almost touching". Mooney judged that it "must have killed nearly half the warriors" [1]. Survivors fought hand to hand with revolvers, knives and war clubs. Captain George Wallace was the only officer killed [1]. The Catholic priest Father Francis Craft was "stabbed through the lungs" while ministering to the dying [1].

The Hotchkiss guns then sent "a storm of shells and bullets among the women and children, who had gathered in front of the tipis" [1]. People fled into a ravine and across open country, followed by soldiers and shellfire. Mooney, who interviewed survivors and walked the ground, wrote: "There can be no question that the pursuit was simply a massacre, where fleeing women, with infants in their arms, were shot down after resistance had ceased" [1]. Commissioner of Indian Affairs Thomas Morgan reported bodies of women and children "scattered along a distance of two miles" [1]. The Oglala leader American Horse, who had stayed loyal to the government, said a woman "with an infant in her arms" was killed "as she almost touched the flag of truce" [3].

Mooney noted that "strict orders" had been given "that women and children were not to be hurt", and blamed "infuriated soldiers whose comrades had just been shot down", many of them new recruits [1].

Whether soldiers were hit by their own crossfire was disputed. General Miles believed "some casualties were suffered at the hands of our own men"; the inquiry officers found the evidence "fails to establish" it [14]. Horn Cloud said "Soldiers shot into one another" [11], and Eastman believed most of the soldiers' losses came from their own comrades [6].

The dead and wounded

Lakota. No exact count exists. The Adjutant-General reported 128 killed, Commissioner Morgan 146, General Miles about 200 and General Leonard Colby of the Nebraska militia about 220. Agent Royer telegraphed that about 300 had been killed, and Mooney thought the total, counting later deaths from wounds and exposure, "was probably very nearly 300" [1]. This page gives about 150 to 300. A blizzard followed, and the dead were buried in a long trench on New Year's Day 1891. Four babies were found alive under the snow; only one lived [1].

Army. In February 1891 the Secretary of War gave the 7th Cavalry's losses as one officer and 25 men killed and 35 wounded [14]. The Adjutant-General's later list gave 31 soldiers killed, and Mooney noted that one or two of the wounded died afterwards [1]. This page gives about 31.

Care for the wounded at Pine Ridge

At Pine Ridge Agency the Episcopal missionary the Rev. Charles Cook gave up his chapel, the Church of the Holy Cross, as a hospital, "in which the Christmas tree still stood" [6]. Eastman wrote: "We tore out the pews and covered the floor with hay and quilts." Mrs Cook, Miss Goodale and Lakota church helpers nursed the wounded, who "would scarcely allow a man in uniform to touch them". Eastman recorded that some of the orphaned children were "adopted into kind Christian families" [6].

The Army inquiry

General Miles relieved Forsyth of command, and on President Benjamin Harrison's instructions an inquiry was held by Major Jacob F. Kent and Captain Frank D. Baldwin [15][14]. Miles's endorsement of 31 January 1891 said Forsyth had ignored "repeated warnings" and that "it is difficult to conceive how a worse disposition of the troops could have been made" [14]. The Secretary of War, Redfield Proctor, disagreed. In his decision, published on 13 February 1891, he wrote that "there is little doubt that the first killing of women and children was by this first fire of the Indians themselves". He restored Forsyth to command [14][15].

What it was called, and the medals

At the time, the Army and most newspapers called it a battle. The Omaha Bee's front page of 30 December 1890 was headed "A BLOODY BATTLE" [8]. Mooney, writing for the government in 1896, used both words. His page headings read "The Wounded Knee Battle", and he called the pursuit "simply a massacre" [1]. Eastman and the Lakota survivors called it a massacre [6].

About 20 soldiers received the Medal of Honor for Wounded Knee; a 2024 Defense Department panel counted 19 [18]. Lakota descendants and some members of Congress have long sought their withdrawal; the panel split three to two for keeping them [17], and in September 2025 the US Defense Secretary, Pete Hegseth, announced that they would stand [16].

A Christian reflection

Wounded Knee shows how fear, false prophecy and poor judgement can lead men who did not set out to murder anyone to do terrible things. Many Lakota had been told their shirts would stop bullets; many soldiers were young recruits told the camp was full of hidden rifles. Some men on both sides acted in good conscience. Big Foot, dying of pneumonia, begged his people to stay calm. Forsyth sent his own surgeon to the sick chief and ordered that the women and children be spared. Father Craft was stabbed while praying with the dying. Yet women and children were shot down as they ran, and Scripture does not let that be excused: the Lord hates "hands that shed innocent blood" (Proverbs 6:16–17). That same week a chapel with its Christmas tree still standing became a hospital, and Christian families took in orphans. An honest account keeps both the sin and the mercy.

Sources

Key facts