TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
Old West › Fort Smith National Historic Site

Fort Smith National Historic Site

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 2 sources (1 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.

Fort Smith National Historic Site stands on the Arkansas River at Fort Smith, Arkansas, on the old border between the state and Indian Territory, now Oklahoma. Two army forts were built here in the 19th century, but the place is best remembered for what came after them: the federal court of Judge Isaac C. Parker, whose deputy marshals rode out into the Territory after murderers, horse thieves and whisky runners. Today the National Park Service looks after the old courthouse and jail, a reconstructed gallows and the remains of the first fort.

Two forts

The first Fort Smith was set up on 25 December 1817 by Major William Bradford, on a rocky point where the Poteau River meets the Arkansas. Its job was to keep the peace between the Osage, who had long hunted this country, and Cherokee families who had moved west from their homelands in the south-east. The army left in 1824 for Fort Gibson, further up the river, and the first fort fell into ruin.

A second, larger fort was begun in 1838, during the years when the Cherokee, Choctaw and other south-eastern nations were being forced west along the routes now known as the Trail of Tears; many passed through Fort Smith. In the 1840s, when Zachary Taylor was in command, it became a supply depot for the army's posts in Indian Territory. It was also a stop on the Butterfield Overland Mail stage route from 1858. Confederate troops held it early in the Civil War until Union forces took it in 1863, and the army finally left in 1871. A small town had grown up around the fort, and it kept the fort's name.

The court for Indian Territory

The US District Court for the Western District of Arkansas had an unusual job. Besides western Arkansas, it was responsible for federal crimes in the whole of Indian Territory, a huge area where the tribal courts could try their own citizens but had no power over outsiders. Outlaws of every kind slipped across the line to hide there. The court moved to Fort Smith after the Civil War and in November 1872 into the empty army buildings, with the courtroom in the old barracks and the jail in the basement beneath it. Its early years were troubled by scandal, and both the marshal and the judge had resigned by 1874.

In 1875 President Ulysses S. Grant appointed Isaac C. Parker, a 36-year-old former congressman from Missouri, to clean up the court. Parker opened his first session on 10 May 1875 and served for 21 years, until his death in November 1896. His court often sat six days a week. On his first day he commissioned Bass Reeves, who became one of the most famous deputy US marshals of all.

The deputies

The marshal at Fort Smith employed as many as two hundred deputies at a time, who rode out for weeks at a time with a wagon, a cook and a posse, carrying warrants and bringing prisoners back in chains. The work was dangerous and badly paid: deputies earned fees and mileage rather than a salary, and dozens were killed in the line of duty. Their story is told in the site's exhibits and remembered at the national museum of the United States Marshals Service, which opened in Fort Smith in 2023. The Dalton brothers rode for the court for a time before turning outlaw themselves (see Dalton Gang), and the court later led the hunt for the Doolin–Dalton Gang in the Territory. Belle Starr was among the many who stood trial there.

The "hanging judge"

Parker is remembered as the "hanging judge". In just over 21 years his court heard more than 13,000 cases. He sentenced 160 people to death, and 79 of them were hanged; the rest died in jail, won appeals, or were pardoned or had their sentences reduced. Six men were hanged together on the gallows on 3 September 1875, a spectacle that drew crowds and reporters from far away.

The legend can hide the man. Murder and rape carried a mandatory death sentence under federal law, so the sentence was not his choice once a jury had convicted, and near the end of his life Parker told a newspaper that he personally favoured abolishing capital punishment. He also spoke up for the rights of the Native nations under their treaties. For his first fourteen years there was no ordinary appeal from his court; from 1889 death sentences could be appealed to the US Supreme Court, which overturned many of them, to Parker's annoyance. Congress cut back the court's territory in 1883, 1889 and 1895, and on 1 September 1896 its authority over Indian Territory ended altogether. Parker died ten weeks later.

The site today

Fort Smith was made a National Historic Site and a National Historic Landmark in 1961. Visitors can see the foundations of the first fort, the commissary building of about 1838, the restored courtroom and the cramped basement jail known as "Hell on the Border", and a reconstruction of the gallows. A walking trail along the river has displays on the Trail of Tears.

On screen

Fort Smith is where Mattie Ross goes to hire Rooster Cogburn in True Grit, both in True Grit (1969) and in True Grit (2010). Judge Parker's court also appears in Hang 'Em High (1968), where Pat Hingle's Judge Fenton is widely seen as loosely based on him.

Key facts

  • Location: Fort Smith, Arkansas, on the Arkansas River
  • First fort: 1817–1824; second fort: 1838–1871
  • Federal court at the fort: from 1872; Judge Isaac C. Parker, 1875–1896
  • Death sentences under Parker: 160, of which 79 were carried out
  • Protected: National Historic Site and National Historic Landmark, 1961
  • Country: United States (Wikidata P17)
  • Located in: Sebastian County (Wikidata P131)
  • Instance of: National Historic Site (Wikidata P31)
  • National Historic Site: 13 Sept 1961 (Wikipedia infobox)

See also

Nearby

Sources

  1. Fort Smith National Historic Site - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikidata: Q3078083 wikidata.org
  3. Wikimedia Commons: Fortsmithhist.jpg commons.wikimedia.org