The Long Trail: How Cowboys & Longhorns Opened the West (1976)
The Long Trail: How Cowboys & Longhorns Opened the West is a 1976 popular history by Gardner Soule, published by McGraw-Hill in the American Trails Series.
Background
Confidence: High
The rating on this section covers the publication facts below, not the accuracy of Soule's history.
The book was issued at New York in 1976: xii, 341 pages, plus four leaves of plates, with a bibliography (pages 327–331) and an index. The ISBN is 0-07-059765-0 and the Library of Congress number is 76-016168. Orlan Sawey, reviewing it in 1977, said the American Trails Series was edited by A. B. Guthrie Jr.. Charles S. Peterson, in the same year, also placed the book in that McGraw-Hill series.
The book
Soule's declared intent, as Peterson reported it, was to trace the cattle industry as an influence in opening the West and to write something of a social history. The approach is mainly chronological from the post-Civil War frontier, with almost annual chapters for the earlier decades and less emphasis after 1885. Both Peterson and Sawey note that Soule's chief printed source, named in the book, is J. Marvin Hunter's The Trail Drivers of Texas. A catalogue note summarises the book as an account of Texans turning, after the Civil War, to raising, rounding up and driving cattle to railheads in Kansas or to buyers elsewhere in the Midwest. The book itself has not been summarised here beyond those catalogue and review statements.
Needs further sources.
Reception
Confidence: High
The rating on this section covers the existence and tenor of the two 1977 reviews, not a judgement that Soule's account is sound. Both reviewers found the book unreliable.
Peterson, then co-editor of The Western Historical Quarterly, called it "something of a disappointment": choppy and episodic because of its heavy use of Hunter, too tightly bound to Texas, and at points "misleading." He objected to what he called "outdated social attitudes" in early chapters, including references to Mexicans, Mexican Americans and Indians, and thought the account of events leading to the Battle of San Jacinto (page 21) distorted. He also criticised the maps.
Sawey, in Western American Literature, called it "a work of great but unfulfilled promise," judged the organisation within chapters "chaotic," and wrote that "a major defect of the book is its historical inaccuracy." Among errors he noted were, on page 28, the "now discredited theory" that "gringo" comes from "Green Grow the Lilacs," and, on page 102, the placing of Williamson County, Texas, between Cameron and Hidalgo counties. The remainder of his examples was not available in the portion of the review that could be read without a subscription.
Why it matters
The book is Soule's only title on cowboys and the cattle trails, and it belongs to a well-known popular series. The two contemporary reviews, however, caution against using it as a reliable history.
Film adaptations
No film version is known.
Key facts
- Author: Gardner Soule
- Year: 1976
- Publisher: McGraw-Hill, New York
- Pages: xii, 341, plus plates
- ISBN: 0-07-059765-0
- LCCN: 76-016168
- Series: American Trails Series
- Type: non-fiction (popular history)
See also
Sources
- OL4885942M - openlibrary.org openlibrary.org
- OL4480953W - openlibrary.org openlibrary.org
- Longtrailhowcowb0000soul - Internet Archive archive.org
- Br trail - sandiegohistory.org sandiegohistory.org
- Br trail - Internet Archive web.archive.org
- Wal.1977.0067 - doi.org doi.org
- OL894193A - openlibrary.org openlibrary.org
