TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
Old West › Vigilantism

Vigilantism

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 6 sources (5 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.

Vigilantism means private citizens taking the law into their own hands: catching, judging and punishing people they believe are criminals, without any lawful authority. On the American frontier, where courts were few and sheriffs were far away or not trusted, groups of settlers sometimes formed "vigilance committees". Some saw themselves as restoring order; their critics saw lynch mobs. Because there was no proper trial, the guilt of many of those hanged was never tested in a court, and historians still disagree over whether some of them, such as Henry Plummer, the sheriff of Bannack, were innocent.

Why it happened

New mining camps and cattle towns often grew far faster than any government could follow. A gold camp might hold thousands of people within weeks, with gold dust as money and no judge for hundreds of miles. Where the law did exist, it could be weak, slow or corrupt. Vigilance committees usually claimed they were filling that gap, and many of their members were leading businessmen and officials.

Famous examples

San Francisco, 1851 and 1856

After the California gold rush swelled San Francisco from a small town into a crowded city, the San Francisco Committee of Vigilance formed in 1851 and again in 1856. It hanged a number of men, banished others and forced some officials out of office. Politics played a large part: the 1856 committee was dominated by merchants opposed to the city's party machine. The San Francisco committees became the model that later vigilantes copied.

Montana, 1863 to 1864

In the gold camps of Bannack and Virginia City, robberies and murders on the trails led to the Vigilance Committee of Alder Gulch in December 1863. In the first weeks of 1864 the vigilantes hanged around twenty men they said were road agents, including Henry Plummer, the sheriff of Bannack, who was accused of leading the gang. How organised that gang really was is still debated. Vigilante hangings continued around Helena later in the 1860s, and in 1884 ranchers led by Granville Stuart hunted down horse and cattle thieves in central and eastern Montana, a campaign remembered as "Stuart's Stranglers".

Indiana, 1868

In southern Indiana, vigilantes ended the Reno Gang of train robbers by lynching ten of its members in 1868, three of them Reno brothers. Nobody was ever charged.

Range wars and regulators

Cattlemen sometimes used the language of vigilantism to justify violence against small ranchers, homesteaders and alleged rustlers. The Johnson County War of 1892 in Wyoming is the best-known case. In New Mexico, the Lincoln County Regulators took their name from an older tradition of "regulators", armed citizens who claimed to enforce justice themselves.

In Westerns

Lynch mobs and vigilantes are a common theme in Western films. The Ox-Bow Incident (1943) follows a posse that hangs three innocent men, and in Hang 'Em High (1968) Clint Eastwood plays a man who survives a lynching and becomes a lawman.

See also

Key facts

Sources

  1. Vigilantism - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikidata: Q124653834 wikidata.org
  3. The Vigilantes of Montana gutenberg.org
  4. "New Albany Tragedy" (1868 newspaper editorial) nafclibrary.historyit.com
  5. Report of the New Albany lynchings timesmachine.nytimes.com
  6. More on Vigilantes and Vigilantism mhs.mt.gov
  7. Wikimedia Commons: The Bostonians Paying the Excise-Man, or Tarring %26 Feathering MET DP827941.jpg commons.wikimedia.org