TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
People › Frontier folk › Native peoples › Comanche

Comanche

Either side · Part of Frontier folk

Some statements on this page are still being checked and are marked "Needs further sources".

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 3 sources. See sources.

The Comanche were the dominant power of the southern Plains, and classic Westerns set many Texas stories against them.

Quanah Parker (died 1911), leader of the Kwahadi (Quahada) Comanche. Undated, probably 1890s.

Quanah Parker (died 1911), leader of the Kwahadi (Quahada) Comanche. Undated, probably 1890s.

Posed photograph · Unknown · c.1890s (undated on NARA record) · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chief_Quanah_Parker_of_the_Kwahadi_Comanche.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: author unknown and work made/published more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(3))

In classic Westerns

In films such as The Searchers (1956) and Two Rode Together (1961) Comanche bands hold white captives, and the drama turns on their recovery. Later films such as The Last Hunt and Comanche Station vary the picture. Named leaders such as Quanah Parker appear in a few titles.

  • Naming: Named as the sources and films name them; no generic label is used.
  • Role in the story: Varies from film to film: allies, enemies, families, or the centre of the story.

Sub-types

Chiefs and leaders

Named Comanche leaders as the films show them.

Tosawa (Tosahwi, "White Knife"), a Penateka Comanche leader, photographed by William S. Soule at Fort Sill in the early 1870s.

Tosawa (Tosahwi, "White Knife"), a Penateka Comanche leader, photographed by William S. Soule at Fort Sill in the early 1870s.

Posed photograph · William S. Soule · early 1870s · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cabinet_Card_of_Comanche_Chief_Tosawa_by_W._S._Soule.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: photographer William S. Soule died 1908, more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(2)) · Band name to be confirmed.

Scouts and trackers

Comanche scouts, trackers and guides, often serving with the army.

Needs a photo

Raiding bands (as films show them)

Films that show a Comanche war party or raiding band, described in each film's own terms and by its named leader where there is one.

Needs a photo

Peoples and families

Films that portray Comanche people and their home life, or name the Comanche at all.

Needs a photo

In history

Documented history from period sources. The film portrayal is described above under "In classic Westerns"; this section is kept separate.

A Santa Fe trader writing in 1844 notes that the Comanche fought with short-handled lances, quoting the saying "that cowards only need long weapons". An army officer met a chief of the Southern Comanche in 1849. Period records name Comanche bands, among them the Kwahadi (Quanah Parker's band) and the Penateka (Tosawa's band). (Needs further sources: Tosawa's band is named in one record only.)

A Texas Ranger's memoir of 1875–81 names Comanche, Lipan, Kickapoo and Kiowa raiders who timed attacks on Texas settlements by the full moon. (Needs further sources: one source only; this is reported as that writer's account, not stated as fact. No specific raid is described on this page until three sources agree.)

How the films differ

Films often show a generic Plains people with no band identity. Period writers named the Comanche and their bands, and the photographs show named leaders.

Films

#FilmHow it qualifiesFrom the wiki's summary
1The Searchers (1956)Chiefs and leaders; Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesAfter the Civil War, a former Confederate soldier and his adopted nephew spend years searching Texas and beyond for a young niece taken in a Comanche raid.
2The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)Chiefs and leaders; Peoples and familiesA Missouri farmer whose family is killed during the Civil War becomes a feared gunfighter seeking revenge.
3The Lone Ranger (2013)Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesTonto (Johnny Depp) narrates the adventures of John Reid, the Lone Ranger (Armie Hammer).
4Red River (1948)Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesA fictional account of the first cattle drive up the Chisholm Trail from Texas to Kansas, and the bitter feud it sparks between a hard rancher and his adopted son.
5Hostiles (2017)Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesIn 1892, a hardened cavalry captain is ordered to escort a dying Cheyenne war chief and his family back to their homeland in Montana.
6Red Sun (1971)Chiefs and leaders; Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesRed Sun (1971) is an international Western directed by Terence Young, starring Charles Bronson, Toshirō Mifune as a samurai, Alain Delon, Ursula Andress and Capucine.
7Two Rode Together (1961)Chiefs and leaders; Peoples and familiesJohn Ford directs James Stewart and Richard Widmark in a story drawn from Will Cook's 1959 novel Comanche Captives, with Shirley Jones, Linda Cristal and Andy Devine in support.
8Comanche Station (1960)Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesComanche Station (1960) is a CinemaScope Western directed by Budd Boetticher, starring Randolph Scott as Jefferson Cody, who rescues a woman from the Comanche and must see her home.
9Duel at Diablo (1966)Peoples and familiesA scout out for revenge, a horse breaker and a cavalry troop escorting a wagon of ammunition are surrounded by Apaches.
10The Last Wagon (1956)Peoples and familiesThe Last Wagon (1956) is a CinemaScope Western co-written and directed by Delmer Daves, starring Richard Widmark as 'Comanche' Todd, a man wanted for murder who must lead the survivors of an attack to safety, with Felicia Farr and Tommy Rettig.
11Lone Star (1952)Peoples and familiesLone Star (1952) is a Western directed by Vincent Sherman, starring Clark Gable as Devereaux Burke, an agent for Andrew Jackson in the push to annex Texas, with Ava Gardner and Broderick Crawford.
12Savage Sam (1963)Peoples and familiesSee the film page.
13Eagle's Wing (1979)Peoples and familiesA white trapper and a Comanche warrior compete to own a magnificent white stallion.
14Last of the Comanches (1953)Chiefs and leaders; Raiding bands (as films show them); Peoples and familiesLast of the Comanches (1953) is a Western directed by André de Toth, starring Broderick Crawford, Barbara Hale and Lloyd Bridges.
15Comanche (1956)Chiefs and leaders; Peoples and familiesComanche (1956) is a CinemaScope cavalry Western directed by George Sherman, starring Dana Andrews as the scout Jim Read, with Kent Smith as Quanah Parker and Linda Cristal, set in 1875.

Films are listed in order of popularity, with older classics given extra weight. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).

See also

Sources

  1. Commerce of the Prairies, part 2 (Josiah Gregg; Thwaites ed., Early Western Travels vol. 20), Arthur H. Clark, Cleveland 1905, 1844 (accessed 28 October 2026)
  2. Six Years with the Texas Rangers, 1875 to 1881 (James B. Gillett), Von Boeckmann-Jones, Austin, 1921 (accessed 28 October 2026)
  3. The Prairie Traveler: A Hand-Book for Overland Expeditions (Randolph B. Marcy, Capt. U.S. Army), Harper & Brothers, New York, published by War Department authority, 1859 (accessed 28 October 2026)