TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
History › Frontier thesis

Frontier thesis (1893)

12 July 1893 · World's Columbian Exposition, Chicago, Illinois, US (American Historic

Photo: Unknown photographer · Public domain · source

How well sourced: 6 sources (5 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.

The frontier thesis is the idea, put forward by the young historian Frederick Jackson Turner in 1893, that the westward-moving frontier had shaped American character and institutions. Turner built his argument on a census report of the time, which said that a continuous frontier line could no longer be drawn on the map. To him, the passing of the frontier "closed the first period of American history". His essay became one of the most influential pieces ever written about the West, and the "closing of the frontier" in 1890 is still a common way to mark the end of the Old West.

The census line

From 1790 the US census had mapped the westward spread of settlement. The frontier was treated as the edge of settled country, where there were at least two people to the square mile. After the 1890 census the Superintendent of the Census reported:

"Up to and including 1880 the country had a frontier of settlement, but at present the unsettled area has been so broken into by isolated bodies of settlement that there can hardly be said to be a frontier line."

The frontier, the report went on, could therefore no longer have a place in the census tables. Turner opened his paper with this passage and called it the official mark of "the closing of a great historic movement".

Turner and his paper

Turner was born in Portage, Wisconsin, in 1861. He studied at the University of Wisconsin and Johns Hopkins University, became a professor of history at Wisconsin in 1892 and moved to Harvard in 1910. He died in 1932.

He read "The Significance of the Frontier in American History" to the American Historical Association in Chicago on 12 July 1893, while the city was hosting the World's Columbian Exposition. Buffalo Bill's Wild West was playing beside the fairground that summer, so two very different pictures of the frontier were on show in Chicago at once (see Wild West shows). The paper drew little notice at first, but within a few years it had changed the way Americans wrote about their history.

The argument

Turner's central claim was that "the existence of an area of free land, its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward, explain American development". In Europe a frontier was a fortified border running through crowded country. In America it was the moving edge of settlement, where society was "continually beginning over again". Turner believed this constant new start had shaped the American people. He argued that the frontier:

  • mixed successive waves of immigrants into a "composite nationality";
  • strengthened the national government;
  • encouraged self-reliance, democracy and individualism;
  • gave the American mind its practical, inventive and restless streak.

He ended: "four centuries from the discovery of America, at the end of a hundred years of life under the Constitution, the frontier has gone, and with its going has closed the first period of American history."

Criticism and legacy

For a generation Turner's thesis dominated the study of American history, and his students carried it into universities across the country. Later historians have challenged it. Some argued that it said too little about the peoples already living in the West, including Native Americans and Hispanic settlers, or about the women, immigrants and Black and Asian Americans who also shaped the region. Others pointed out that settlement went on long after 1890, that more land was homesteaded after that date than before it (see Homestead Acts), and that the West did not stop being a distinct region when the census line vanished. Historians still debate how much of Turner's picture holds, but most agree that he set the questions the field has argued about ever since.

Legend and history

  • The frontier "closed" in 1890. This is a census statement about a line on a map, not an event. Ranching, mining and homesteading carried on into the 20th century, and Oklahoma, New Mexico and Arizona did not become states until 1907–12.
  • "Free land". Turner's phrase meant land open to American settlement. The land was not empty: it had been lived on by Native nations, and much of it came to the United States by treaty, purchase and war.

Key facts

  • Census report: issued after the 1890 census by the Superintendent of the Census
  • Turner's paper: "The Significance of the Frontier in American History", read to the American Historical Association in Chicago on 12 July 1893
  • Turner: born 1861, Portage, Wisconsin; professor at the University of Wisconsin, then Harvard from 1910; died 1932
  • Census definition of the frontier: the edge of settlement with two or more people per square mile
  • Frederick Jackson Turner read 'The Significance of the Frontier in American History' at a meeting of the American Historical Association in Chicago on 12 July 1893, during the World's Columbian Exposition (University of Wisconsin; National Humanities Center).
  • Turner opened with the Superintendent of the Census's 1890 bulletin, which said there could 'hardly be said to be a frontier line' any longer (Turner's text, University of Wisconsin Digital Collections).
  • Turner concluded that the frontier had gone and with it had 'closed the first period of American history' (Turner's text).
  • Later historians challenged the thesis for leaving out many of the peoples who shaped the West; homesteading went on well after 1890 (NPS, Homestead by the numbers).

See also

Sources

  1. F. J. Turner, 'The Significance of the Frontier in American History' (1893) - University of Wisconsin Digital Collections digicoll.library.wisc.edu
  2. Turner, 'The Significance of the Frontier' (excerpt) - National Humanities Center nationalhumanitiescenter.org
  3. Timeline 1889–1893: Turner's benchmarks - UW–Madison History Department history.wisc.edu
  4. Homesteading by the Numbers - Homestead National Historical Park (NPS) nps.gov
  5. Frontier Thesis - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
  6. Wikidata: Q2917318 wikidata.org
  7. Wikimedia Commons: Frederick Jackson Turner.jpg commons.wikimedia.org