Contention City, Arizona
Contention City, often just called Contention, was a mill town on the San Pedro River in Cochise County, Arizona, where silver ore from the Tombstone mines was crushed. It was laid out in 1879, peaked in the mid-1880s with perhaps 200 people, and was empty by about 1890. Only scattered adobe walls and foundations are left, but the name lives on in Western fiction, most famously as the railway town at the end of 3:10 to Yuma.
A disputed claim
The story goes that two prospectors, Ed Williams and Jack Friday, found the silver lode when their runaway mules dragged a chain across the ground and scraped the dirt off a gleaming vein. The mules had wandered to the camp of Ed Schieffelin, the man who had discovered Tombstone's silver, and Schieffelin claimed the ground was his. The claim was split: Williams and Friday named their half the Grand Central, and Schieffelin named his the Contention, after the argument.
A mill town
Tombstone had no water to process its ore, so mills were built down on the San Pedro River. Contention City grew up between two of them, the Head Center and the Contention mills, which crushed the ore into powder ready for smelting. The town was surveyed in 1879 and soon had a post office, a hotel, saloons, stores, a butcher, a blacksmith and a Chinese laundry. Stage lines ran to Tombstone and Tucson, and in 1882 the New Mexico and Arizona Railroad reached the town.
The Earps at Contention
After the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, Ike Clanton tried to have Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday tried at Contention, but no trial was held. In March 1882, after Morgan Earp was murdered in Tombstone, Wyatt and his party brought Morgan's body to Contention to be sent home by rail. In the late 1880s, Cochise County sheriff John Slaughter tracked members of an outlaw gang to a house in Contention, and in the shoot-out that followed one of the outlaws was killed and Slaughter had an earlobe clipped by a bullet.
Decline
The railway was soon extended to Fairbank, closer to Tombstone, and once water was found at Tombstone the river mills were no longer needed. When the Tombstone mines flooded in 1886 and 1887 the mills shut, and the people left. The post office closed in 1888. The townsite is now part of the San Pedro Riparian National Conservation Area, and visitors can walk to it along the river.
In fiction and film
Elmore Leonard set his 1953 short story "Three-Ten to Yuma" in Contention, where a deputy must hold an outlaw until the prison train arrives. Both films of the story end there: 3:10 to Yuma (1957) and 3:10 to Yuma (2007). In Wyatt Earp (1994) the Earps board a train at a halt signed "Contention".
See also
Nearby
- Tombstone, Arizona 14 km
- Bird Cage Theatre 14 km
- Fort Huachuca 28 km
- Fort Bowie 84 km
- Tucson, Arizona 85 km
- Shakespeare, New Mexico 151 km
Key facts
- Founded/established: 1880 (Wikidata P571)
- Country: United States (Wikidata P17)
- Located in: Cochise County (Wikidata P131)
- Instance of: ghost town (Wikidata P31)
Sources
- Contention City, Arizona - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5165100 wikidata.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Contention Hotel 1880.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
