Cattle barons, crooked railroad men and bankers
Usually bad · Part of Frontier folk
Some statements on this page are still being checked and are marked "Needs further sources".
Behind the hired guns stand the men with money: the cattle baron who wants the whole valley, the railroad man who wants the right of way, and the banker who holds the mortgage.
In classic Westerns
The film cattle baron is a proud, powerful old rancher who thinks the open range is his by right and will not share water or grass with newcomers; sometimes he is redeemed, often he is not. The crooked railroad man and the banker are more modern villains, using contracts, foreclosures and hired killers to take land, as with Morton in Once Upon a Time in the West (1968). These stories usually set ordinary settlers or small ranchers against concentrated power.
- Look: The big ranch house, a fine suit or frock coat, a gold watch chain; a private railway car.
- Values: Possession and control; the law bent to wealth.
- Role in the story: The power behind the villainy, rarely the man who fights the final duel.
Sub-types
Cattle barons and land barons
Big ranchers and landowners who try to drive out homesteaders and small outfits.

Charles Goodnight (1836–1929), Texas cattleman and trail-blazer. Date unknown.
Posed photograph · Unknown · Undated · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Goodnite.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: author unknown and work made/published more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(3)) · Placeholder: very small copy, provenance and date to be confirmed.
Crooked railroad men
Railroad tycoons and agents who use killers and fraud to get land or a route.
Bankers and land grabbers
Bankers, speculators and town bosses who foreclose, swindle or hire guns.
In history
Documented history from period sources. The film portrayal is described above under "In classic Westerns"; this section is kept separate.
Big cattlemen such as Charles Goodnight built ranches across the Texas Panhandle after the 1870s. (Needs further sources: no life of Goodnight has been read yet.) Railway and express companies carried the trade that made such ranches pay.
Some cattlemen acted outside the law, as in the Johnson County War (see Hired guns and range bullies), but the record of their dealings is mixed. Each charge needs its own sources, and none is stated here as fact.
How the films differ
Films make the rich rancher, railway boss or banker the stock villain. The record is mixed and has to be judged case by case.
Films
| # | Film | How it qualifies | From the wiki's summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) | Crooked railroad men | Sergio Leone's epic Western about a struggle over land as the railroad pushes west. |
| 2 | The Wild Bunch (1969) | Crooked railroad men | An ageing gang of outlaws on the US–Mexico border struggles to adapt to the modern world of 1913. |
| 3 | Shane (1953) | Cattle barons and land barons | A mysterious drifter turns up in 1889 Wyoming Territory and stays to help a homesteading family. |
| 4 | El Dorado (1966) | Cattle barons and land barons | A gunfighter rides to the aid of an old friend, now a hard-drinking sheriff, who is trying to protect a ranching family from a rival rancher set on taking their water. |
| 5 | They Call Me Trinity (1970) | Bankers and land grabbers | Two half-brothers, Trinity and Bambino, defend a Mormon settlement from bandits and a land-grabbing major. |
| 6 | Open Range (2003) | Cattle barons and land barons | Two cattlemen who drive their herds across open range, played by Robert Duvall and Kevin Costner, clash with a rancher who controls a nearby town. |
| 7 | How the West Was Won (1962) | Crooked railroad men | An epic that follows the settling of the West across several decades. |
| 8 | The Big Country (1958) | Cattle barons and land barons | Gregory Peck leads an epic Western about a feud between ranching families. |
| 9 | Pale Rider (1985) | Bankers and land grabbers | A mysterious preacher rides into a mining camp and stands with the prospectors against a powerful rival. |
| 10 | Joe Kidd (1972) | Cattle barons and land barons | A former bounty hunter is hired by a wealthy landowner to track down Luis Chama, a Mexican revolutionary fighting for land reform. |
| 11 | Appaloosa (2008) | Cattle barons and land barons | Two hired lawmen take on a ruthless rancher in a New Mexico mining town, and the arrival of a widow puts their partnership to the test. |
| 12 | The Professionals (1966) | Cattle barons and land barons | Four mercenaries are hired to rescue a kidnapped wife from a revolutionary leader during the Mexican Revolution. |
| 13 | The Great Silence (1968) | Bankers and land grabbers | Sergio Corbucci's snowbound spaghetti Western stars Jean-Louis Trintignant and Klaus Kinski. |
| 14 | Silverado (1985) | Cattle barons and land barons | Lawrence Kasdan's Western ensemble stars Kevin Kline, Scott Glenn, Danny Glover and Kevin Costner. |
| 15 | The Salvation (2014) | Cattle barons and land barons | The Salvation (2014) is a Danish Western directed by Kristian Levring, who co-wrote it with Anders Thomas Jensen, starring Mads Mikkelsen and Eva Green with Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Jonathan Pryce and Eric Cantona. |
| 16 | Rio Lobo (1970) | Bankers and land grabbers | After the Civil War, a former Union colonel sets out to find the traitor who sold secrets to the Confederates, a search that brings him to a Texas town run by crooks. |
| 17 | The Missouri Breaks (1976) | Cattle barons and land barons | Arthur Penn's Western pairs Marlon Brando and Jack Nicholson, with a score by John Williams. |
| 18 | The Man from Laramie (1955) | Cattle barons and land barons | A stranger crosses a cattle baron and his violent son by going to work for one of their oldest rivals. |
| 19 | Heaven's Gate (1980) | Cattle barons and land barons | Michael Cimino's epic is loosely based on the Johnson County War. |
Films are listed in order of popularity, with older classics given extra weight. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).
See also
Sources
- The Story of the Outlaw (Emerson Hough), Outing Publishing Company, New York, 1907 (accessed 28 October 2026)
