TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
People › Frontier folk › Preachers, pastors and circuit riders

Preachers, pastors and circuit riders

Usually good · Part of Frontier folk

Some statements on this page are still being checked and are marked "Needs further sources".

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 2 sources. See sources.

The frontier preacher brings the Gospel, the hymn book and the Sunday service to raw towns and lonely homesteads.

The Rev. William Wesley Van Orsdel, "Brother Van", Methodist preacher in Montana, about 1915. A late photograph of a man who began riding circuit in the 1870s.

The Rev. William Wesley Van Orsdel, "Brother Van", Methodist preacher in Montana, about 1915. A late photograph of a man who began riding circuit in the 1870s.

Posed photograph · Unknown · c.1915 · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:William_Wesley_Van_Orsdel.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: author unknown and work made/published more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(3))

In classic Westerns

In the best classic Westerns the preacher is a man of quiet courage who builds a church in a lawless town, buries the dead, marries the young couple and stands up to the bully; Stars in My Crown (1950) is the fullest portrait. The circuit rider travels from settlement to settlement with a Bible in his saddlebags. Some films give a gunman the look of a preacher, as in Pale Rider (1985), and a few later films make the clergyman a hypocrite or villain; those are noted separately, because the wiki's True Grit rating counts Christians shown as villains against a film.

  • Look: Black frock coat, flat-crowned hat, a Bible; the circuit rider on horseback with saddlebags.
  • Values: Faith, mercy, courage and the building of a community around a church.
  • Role in the story: Moral voice of the town, peacemaker, or a man forced to choose between turning the other cheek and defending his flock.

Sub-types

Town preachers and pastors

The minister of the settled town, who preaches on Sunday and stands with the townspeople during the week.

Needs a photo: A frontier church and its pastor, 1870s–1900s.

Circuit riders and missionaries

Travelling preachers, mostly Methodist in history, and missionaries to settlers and to Native peoples.

A Methodist circuit rider fording a river: an engraving published in 1880. This is an illustration, not a photograph.

A Methodist circuit rider fording a river: an engraving published in 1880. This is an illustration, not a photograph.

Art (an engraving, not a photograph) · Unknown engraver; published by W. H. Daniels · 1880 · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Methodist_circuit_rider_in_river.png · Licence: Public domain – UK: author unknown and work made/published more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(3))

Priests and padres

Catholic priests, usually in Mexican villages or missions on the border, often shown sheltering the weak.

Mission San Xavier del Bac, near Tucson, Arizona Territory, 1880s: a Spanish-era Catholic mission still in use.

Mission San Xavier del Bac, near Tucson, Arizona Territory, 1880s: a Spanish-era Catholic mission still in use.

Photograph · G. H. Rothrock · 1880s · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:San_Xavier_mission,_by_G._H._Rothrock.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: author presumed dead more than 70 years ago (CDPA s.57) · Small copy.

In history

Documented history from period sources. The film portrayal is described above under "In classic Westerns"; this section is kept separate.

Peter Cartwright was a Methodist circuit rider for half a century. His whole library was a pocket Bible, a hymn book and the Methodist book of discipline, carried with a few other good books in his saddle-bags. In the early years the travelling preacher often camped out, as he put it, without fire or food for man or beast. His circuits were on the older frontier of Kentucky and Illinois, not in the Far West.

Later circuit riders carried the same work west. William Wesley Van Orsdel, known as "Brother Van", preached across Montana from the 1870s. (Needs further sources: his life has not yet been checked beyond the photograph record.) In the Southwest, Catholic missions from the Spanish period, such as San Xavier del Bac near Tucson, were still in use.

How the films differ

Films often make the preacher a comic coward or a hypocrite. First-hand accounts show hardy men on horseback who travelled light, endured real hardship and preached the Gospel where there were no churches. On the frontier they were usually respected. (Needs further sources: the accounts read so far come from the older frontier east of the Mississippi.)

Films

#FilmHow it qualifiesFrom the wiki's summary
1Pale Rider (1985)Town preachers and pastorsA mysterious preacher rides into a mining camp and stands with the prospectors against a powerful rival.
2Brimstone (2016)Town preachers and pastorsA woman on the frontier is pursued by a menacing preacher who is set on punishing her.
3Rooster Cogburn (1975)Town preachers and pastorsJohn Wayne returns as the ageing one-eyed marshal Rooster Cogburn, who has lost his badge and is offered a chance to win it back by hunting down a gang of bank robbers.
4The Ballad of Cable Hogue (1970)Town preachers and pastorsSam Peckinpah's gentle comedy follows three years in the life of a failed prospector (Jason Robards) in the Arizona desert as the frontier is closing.
5Duel in the Sun (1946)Town preachers and pastorsAn orphaned Mestiza woman faces prejudice and forbidden love while living with her white relatives on a Texas ranch.
6The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean (1972)Town preachers and pastorsJohn Huston's comedy-drama, from a John Milius script, loosely retells the life of the saloon keeper and self-appointed judge Roy Bean, played by Paul Newman, with Jacqueline Bisset, Ava Gardner and Huston himself.
7The Bravados (1958)Priests and padresThe Bravados (1958) is a CinemaScope Western directed by Henry King, starring Gregory Peck as Jim Douglass, a rancher pursuing four outlaws he believes murdered his wife, with Joan Collins.
8Will Penny (1968)Town preachers and pastorsWill Penny (1968) is a revisionist Western written and directed by Tom Gries, starring Charlton Heston as an ageing cowboy, with Joan Hackett and Donald Pleasence.
9Apache Gold (1963)Circuit riders and missionariesApache Gold (1963), originally Winnetou and also known as Winnetou the Warrior, is a West German Western directed by Harald Reinl, starring Lex Barker and Pierre Brice as the Apache hero Winnetou, with Mario Adorf and Marie Versini.
10Forsaken (2014)Town preachers and pastorsA former gunfighter comes home to reconcile with his father, a minister, and finds the town under threat from a land grabber's gang.
11The Duel (2016)Town preachers and pastors; Circuit riders and missionariesThe Duel is an American Western directed by Kieran Darcy-Smith and written by Matt Cook, starring Liam Hemsworth as David Kingston and Woody Harrelson as Abraham Brant, with Alice Braga and Emory Cohen.
12Buck and the Preacher (1972)Town preachers and pastorsAfter the Civil War, a wagon master guides freed slaves heading west and teams up with a con man posing as a preacher to protect them from raiders.
13Stars in My Crown (1950)Town preachers and pastorsStars in My Crown (1950) is a Western directed by Jacques Tourneur, starring Joel McCrea as Josiah Gray, a preacher whose faith tames an unruly town after the Civil War, with Ellen Drew and Dean Stockwell.
14Guns for San Sebastian (1968)Priests and padresGuns for San Sebastian (1968) is a French Western directed by Henri Verneuil, starring Anthony Quinn as Leon Alastray with Anjanette Comer and Charles Bronson.
15The Outrage (1964)Town preachers and pastorsThe Outrage (1964) is a Western directed by Martin Ritt, a remake of Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon set in the American West, in which four people give conflicting accounts of a crime, starring Paul Newman as the bandit Juan Carrasco, Laurence Harvey, Claire Bloom and Edward G. Robinson.
16Silver Lode (1954)Town preachers and pastorsSilver Lode (1954) is a Technicolor Western directed by Allan Dwan, starring John Payne as Dan Ballard, accused of murder on his wedding day by a marshal played by Dan Duryea, with Lizabeth Scott.
17Damsel (2018)Town preachers and pastorsA pioneer sets off across the frontier to rescue the woman he loves, but things are not what they seem.

Films are listed in order of popularity, with older classics given extra weight. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).

See also

Sources

  1. Autobiography of Peter Cartwright, the Backwoods Preacher (ed. W. P. Strickland), Carlton & Porter, New York, 1857 (accessed 28 October 2026)
  2. Seventy Years on the Frontier (Alexander Majors), Rand, McNally & Co., Chicago, 1893 (accessed 28 October 2026)